fubar57
General
Anyone know if this is an accurate depiction of this aircraft. If so, imma build this sucker as it would fit into my oddball scheme theme.
Geo
Geo
Fw190A-6 Profile Accuracy
- Thread starter fubar57
- Start date
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
vikingBerserker
Lieutenant General
I don't think that is accurate, and the source is probably from The Big Show by Pierre Clostermann. He claims to have shot down a yellow Fw-190. I've seem some of the parts yellow (such as the cowel), but never the entire bottom.
- Thread starter
- #3
fubar57
General
That was my thought too VB but was hoping maybe it was some sort of training or hack aircraft.
- Thread starter
- #4
fubar57
General
Getting interesting. The above FW is on the cover of an Aircam book with the caption "..probably Jg2"Richthoven" training unit, Triqueville, France '43". Inside, is this other profile with the same year but that it was shot down. Not happy until I find an actual photo.
Geo
Geo
I think it is fiction.
Luftwaffe trainers were not painted yellow. In 1942 the elementary trainers,which often came in their original single,light,factory colours,were ordered to receive an overall coat of either RLM 70 or RLM 71 on their upper surfaces. For safety reasons they were also often given yellow wing tips,cowlings or rudders.
Advanced trainers,like the Fw 190 were subject to the same rules as front line fighters. They had often been passed on from the Jagdgeschwader and retained their original camouflage. Their unit markings would be changed or overpainted to denote their new owners.
Captured enemy aircraft used as trainers (obviously not a Fw 190) usually had their undersurfaces painted in RLM 04 (yellow).
Whilst not wanting to get into a Clostermann bashing debate I would say that his book is a self confessed "roman" and should not be taken as a literal history. Well worth a read though.
I'd also say that if you want to make an interesting and unusual model of an Fw 190,why not? It'll certainly stand out on your shelves!
Cheers
Steve
Luftwaffe trainers were not painted yellow. In 1942 the elementary trainers,which often came in their original single,light,factory colours,were ordered to receive an overall coat of either RLM 70 or RLM 71 on their upper surfaces. For safety reasons they were also often given yellow wing tips,cowlings or rudders.
Advanced trainers,like the Fw 190 were subject to the same rules as front line fighters. They had often been passed on from the Jagdgeschwader and retained their original camouflage. Their unit markings would be changed or overpainted to denote their new owners.
Captured enemy aircraft used as trainers (obviously not a Fw 190) usually had their undersurfaces painted in RLM 04 (yellow).
Whilst not wanting to get into a Clostermann bashing debate I would say that his book is a self confessed "roman" and should not be taken as a literal history. Well worth a read though.
I'd also say that if you want to make an interesting and unusual model of an Fw 190,why not? It'll certainly stand out on your shelves!
Cheers
Steve
- Thread starter
- #6
fubar57
General
Thanks for the info Steve. Just a lot of wishful dreaming here and as I said, I need to see an actual photo. A lot of people here with way more knowledge about these things would have mentioned it in the forum by now. Again, thanks for your comments.
Geo
Geo
definately be no photo of that scheme....
Njaco
The Pop-Tart Whisperer
Also found this profile which gives more info...
- Thread starter
- #9
fubar57
General
There's a 190 modeled on this website, Airfix 1/24th Yellow Fw 190 by Erwin Hallemeesch (Don't want to step on anyone's toes by posting the pictures here) that is painted overall yellow with red spinner and rudder, eagle over the exhaust and the markings < + - . No info is supplied about the subject. I wanna do one of these but not if they're incorrect which I'm thinking they are.
Geo
Geo
As a matter of interest the colours perceived by pilots in combat can be surprising. I've even read one encounter report describing a twin engined jet aircraft (probably an Arado 234) as having a pink undersurface. It was almost certainly an effect of the light on an unpainted or light coloured underside. I've read another report in which an RAF pilot reported that the Bf 109s he engaged carried roundels similar to RAF roundels. The most obvious explanation might be that they were not Bf 109s!
A Major Von Graf was shot down on that date in an aircraft supposedly with those codes.It is assumed to have belonged to a blind flying school. The problem now is that the codes for aircraft attached to flying schools comprised four letters (check edit) and no numbers after the WL registration system was superceded in October 1939.
Nothing is impossible,but lots of things are improbable
Steve
Edit. Some aircraft did have a number in their codes. The only one I've found was attached to a glider unit.
A Major Von Graf was shot down on that date in an aircraft supposedly with those codes.It is assumed to have belonged to a blind flying school. The problem now is that the codes for aircraft attached to flying schools comprised four letters (check edit) and no numbers after the WL registration system was superceded in October 1939.
Nothing is impossible,but lots of things are improbable
Steve
Edit. Some aircraft did have a number in their codes. The only one I've found was attached to a glider unit.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #11
fubar57
General
Again Steve, thanks for the info. Was just on the RCUniverse website and the discussion about this (dated 2003) was that Von Graf was actually Hermann Graff(sp) and this would all be explained in the upcoming book "GRAF GRISLAWSKI: A PAIR OF ACES". As I stated before, I know very little on things Luftwaffe and aircraft in general so it's all a very large learning curve.
Geo
Geo
Njaco
The Pop-Tart Whisperer
The 'G3" code was for NJG 101. Was Graf ever flying with that unit?
Something doesn't smell right...
from Wiki...
and from here...
http://www.luftwaffe.cz/graf.html
Something doesn't smell right...
from Wiki...
and from here...
http://www.luftwaffe.cz/graf.html
Last edited:
I have,or had, a copy of Bergstrom's book but I don't remember Graf (one F) being shot down in a yellow 190. He did serve briefly at a fighter training unit,not a blind flying school,before his attachment to JG 50 and I suspect this is the origin of the story.
Steve.
I see I've crossed with the post from "Njaco"
Steve.
I see I've crossed with the post from "Njaco"
Njaco
The Pop-Tart Whisperer
Sorry for spamming but check this out....
Major von Graff's FW-190
This story seems bogus to me. It is not Herman Graf and the 'blind' as mentioned might be an allusion to the statement blind RAF pilots. And apparently this is all attributed to Pierre Closterman.
Major von Graff's FW-190
This story seems bogus to me. It is not Herman Graf and the 'blind' as mentioned might be an allusion to the statement blind RAF pilots. And apparently this is all attributed to Pierre Closterman.
Good grief! I presume "Baron von Ha Ha" is a reference to Lord Haw-Haw.
Anything to do with broadcasts by the Reich Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda is even less reliable than Clostermann!
William Joyce,the man most often assocciated with that nick name,was hanged for treason after the war.
This is bogus.
Steve
Anything to do with broadcasts by the Reich Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda is even less reliable than Clostermann!
William Joyce,the man most often assocciated with that nick name,was hanged for treason after the war.
This is bogus.
Steve
Last edited:
vikingBerserker
Lieutenant General
"Baron von Ha Ha?" 
- Thread starter
- #17
fubar57
General
Thanks for showing interest in the subject guys. I am now believing this to be a figment of someone's imagination and however much as I want a yellow 190, as the saying now goes,"Pics or it didn't happen." If I want to crank out fictitious aircraft, my next model may as well be a purple and green striped P-51 sporting a Tiger tank turret on each wing. EDITBy the by, does anyone else have a copy of the Graf/Grislawski book.
Geo
Geo
Last edited:
Njaco
The Pop-Tart Whisperer
WWI had the "Red Baron"
WWII may have had the "Yellow Count".
WWII may have had the "Yellow Count".
If you must do a Yellow 190, do a captured one there is a predominantly yellow painted one on a Karaya decals sheet if I remember correctly....
Absolutely,plenty of captured examples in all sorts of colours.
I did this nice blue one in the unusual (for me) 1/72 scale.
Steve
