 | Why did D-day even happen?| WW2 General Discuss Why did D-day even happen? in the World War II - General forums; Like the Allies could have easily taken Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Hungary through Italy, and been very close to Berlin, they ... |
|
02-14-2007, 06:51 PM
|
#1 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Edmonton,Alberta
Posts: 2,260
Country:  | Why did D-day even happen?
Like the Allies could have easily taken Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Hungary through Italy, and been very close to Berlin, they could have spearheaded through to Berlin, and if they wanted to take France so bad why nt take them from behind by invading Vichey France, instead of breaking through a heavily defended Atlantic wall, like there is probably details that im not aware of, but yeah, if the Allies had of taken Berlin by invading Slovakia first and moving forward from there, maybe the USSR would never have made it to Germany meaning the Cold War would have went differently
__________________
Hello me...meet the real me.
And my misfits way of life.
A dark black past is my
Most valued possession.
Hindsight is always 20-20,
But looking back its still a bit fuzzy.
Speak of mutually assured destruction?
Nice story...tell it to readers digest!!! | 
|  | |
02-14-2007, 08:11 PM
|
#2 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Orange County, CA
Posts: 8,143
| Why do you want to land and fight in mountainous regions?
A repeat of the italian invasion.
__________________
"Pilot to copilot..... what are those mountain goats doing up here in the clouds?" | |
| | |
02-14-2007, 08:52 PM
|
#3 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Jacksonville, NC
Posts: 3,145
Country:  | Italy saw some very bitter fighting - and is unfortunately a widely unrecognized theater. Sys is right - tough mountain warfare, which is what italy was. Then continuing up north through austria into germany through tyrol alps??? Even passing to the east and launching an attack from slovakia/poland would have been an impractical scenario. Think of supply lines through mountains, arching around throughout half of europe...
__________________
If the Army and the Navy ever look on heaven's scenes, they will find the streets are guarded by United States Marines | |
| | |
02-14-2007, 10:01 PM
|
#4 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Canada
Posts: 2,004
Country: | Plus the fact that many war criminals could have escaped due to the fact that there was nobody to block their retreat in the West. | |
| | |
02-15-2007, 03:50 AM
|
#5 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 12,057
Country:  | It's all a matter of supply. The biggest supply depot was Great Britain, an invasion from anywhere else would have ran out of supply very quickly.
__________________ "When you go home tomorrow, don't expect anyone to know what you have been through. Even if they did know, most people probably wouldn't care anyway. Some of you may get the medals you deserve, many more of you will not. But remember this, all of you are now members of the front-line club, and that is the most exclusive club in the world." - Lt. Col. Matthew Maer CO 1st Battalion, the Princess of Wale's Royal Regiment. Camp Abu Naji, Oct. 2004  To those in that club. | |
| | |
02-15-2007, 04:18 AM
|
#6 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Royal Deeside/St Andrews, Scotland, UK
Posts: 11,247
Country: | Quote:
Originally Posted by plan_D  It's all a matter of supply. The biggest supply depot was Great Britain, an invasion from anywhere else would have ran out of supply very quickly. | Yep, Britain was the base and once in France you have the easiest and quickest route to Berlin with the shortest sea journey. Also if you read about the war in Italy you will see it is much harder going than you suppose with the Germans have multiple Sigfried line style defences (Gothic line etc).
__________________  "Success is not Final, Failure is not Fatal, it is the Courage to Continue that Counts"
Sir Winston Churchill
"To him the people of the world largely owe the Freedom and liberties they enjoy today"
Enscription on Hugh Dowding's (AOC Fighter Command 1936-40) statue in London
Moderator WW2 Talk: A WW2 Discussion Forum | |
| | |
02-15-2007, 10:44 AM
|
#7 | | Der Crewchief
Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Ansbach, Germany
Posts: 29,456
Country:  | There were 2 main reasons why they did not try an major push through Italy.
One as plan_D pointed out was supply. It would have been more difficult to supply through Italy.
Two was the terrain. It would have actually prolonged the war to go through the Alps. Besides as history has allready proven the allies were bogged down for quite some time because of the fierce and well placed German defenses there.
__________________  US Army Blackhawk Crewchief 2000-2006 Classic ww2aircraft.net quotes: fly boy said: "isn't that the first jet bomber? becasue i have flown one in a flight sim before and i know how it handles" "wait what ok who made the b-2 crash come on people that messed up its a b-2" "ah yes the mistel those things are so annoying is games and in real life" | |
| | |
02-15-2007, 11:00 AM
|
#8 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003 Location: UK
Posts: 3,505
Country:  | Britain was (as D & Adler have said) a bloody great depot, aircraft carrier, docks and barracks with just a thin strip of water seperating it from the enemy. The skies to all intense and purposes where ruled by the allies as where the seas the possible landing sites streached along most of the French coast which in turn streached the defending German forces, even Norway was perceived as a possible invasion point and caused forces to be retained there just incase.
I think this was why the only feasable second front with the maximum chance of success was launched from the UK
Last edited by trackend : 02-15-2007 at 11:03 AM.
| |
| | |
02-15-2007, 11:54 AM
|
#9 | | Der Crewchief
Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Ansbach, Germany
Posts: 29,456
Country: | It would have been hell trying to go through the alps with hundreds of thousands of troops and equipment and the Germans would have had the terrain on there side.
Trying going up those mountains with the Germans shooting down on you.
__________________ US Army Blackhawk Crewchief 2000-2006 Classic ww2aircraft.net quotes: fly boy said: "isn't that the first jet bomber? becasue i have flown one in a flight sim before and i know how it handles" "wait what ok who made the b-2 crash come on people that messed up its a b-2" "ah yes the mistel those things are so annoying is games and in real life" | |
| | |
02-15-2007, 12:13 PM
|
#10 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Fresno, CA
Posts: 2,269
Country: | I think it's worth also considering that ending the war earlier through significantly increased efforts would probably result in a weaker US/Britain and a stronger USSR. Why not let the Germans and the Russians grind each other down while we continue to mass resources for a concentrated assault along a easier to manage western front. | 
| | |
02-15-2007, 03:29 PM
|
#11 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Phila, Pa
Posts: 2,381
Country: | Quote:
Originally Posted by DerAdlerIstGelandet
Trying going up those mountains with the Germans shooting down on you.
| Yeah, the terrain in the Alps practically defends itself. | |
| | |
02-16-2007, 10:48 PM
|
#12 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Jacksonville, NC
Posts: 3,145
Country: | Quote:
Originally Posted by DerAdlerIstGelandet There were 2 main reasons why they did not try an major push through Italy.
One as plan_D pointed out was supply. It would have been more difficult to supply through Italy.
Two was the terrain. It would have actually prolonged the war to go through the Alps. Besides as history has allready proven the allies were bogged down for quite some time because of the fierce and well placed German defenses there. | Excuse me sir! I believe I pointed out supply issues first! Give it up 
__________________
If the Army and the Navy ever look on heaven's scenes, they will find the streets are guarded by United States Marines | |
| | |
02-17-2007, 12:22 AM
|
#13 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Orange County, CA
Posts: 8,143
| A Balkan invasion was considered at one time in the war. And FDR and the JCS rejected it outright as being an "adventure" for political reasons and few if any military advantages.
__________________
"Pilot to copilot..... what are those mountain goats doing up here in the clouds?" | |
| | |
02-17-2007, 03:45 AM
|
#14 | | Der Crewchief
Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Ansbach, Germany
Posts: 29,456
Country: | Plus you would have to go through the same kind of terrain as you did in the Alps to get to Germany. Would have taken even longer.
__________________ US Army Blackhawk Crewchief 2000-2006 Classic ww2aircraft.net quotes: fly boy said: "isn't that the first jet bomber? becasue i have flown one in a flight sim before and i know how it handles" "wait what ok who made the b-2 crash come on people that messed up its a b-2" "ah yes the mistel those things are so annoying is games and in real life" | |
| | |
02-17-2007, 05:32 AM
|
#15 | | Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Brisbane Queensland
Posts: 1,549
Country:  | Quote:
Originally Posted by syscom3 A Balkan invasion was considered at one time in the war. And FDR and the JCS rejected it outright as being an "adventure" for political reasons and few if any military advantages. | Yes Sys but Allies didn't want another Gallipoli style invasion as it failed in WW1. But by going through Greece into the Balkans but the Allies were smart to they fooled German Military Intelligence into believing a front invasion would go through the Balkans via Greece etc or Norway or even by France itself by Calais etc. The Italian campaign the Tough Old Gut of Europe was bad enough but Greece would have been just as bad going to the Balkans etc. The Germans had a hell of a time taking Greece in 1941. It wasn't a walk over as they first thought with Greek British and Commonwealth Troops defending every pass and mountain top in a fighting withdrawal. Second Battle of Thermopyle were Australian 6th Division men were defending the pass gave the German Army hell. Only thing the Aussies lacked was air cover of their own and the Germans had air superiority which they used to dislodge the Aussies, but it cost the Germans dearly for every foot of ground won in Greece as it did for Allies in Italy. So Greece via Balkans was out of the question. Good only to keep the Germans guessing and tie down extra divisions that could be used elsewhere | |
| | | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | | | | | Display Modes |  Linear Mode | 
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:43 PM. | | |
